1. Hi there, Guest

    Only registered users can really experience what DLP has to offer. Many forums are only accessible if you have an account. Why don't you register?
    Dismiss Notice

Entry #2

Discussion in 'Q3 - Sept - Redux Deluxe' started by Xiph0, Sep 16, 2020.

Not open for further replies.
  1. Xiph0

    Xiph0 Yoda Admin

    Joined:
    Dec 7, 2005
    Messages:
    9,498
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    West Bank
    The Hogwarts Beach Trip Episode / Harry learns why Albus doesn't drink

    The sun was shining and the ocean was glistening with sunlight, which could damage the eyes as easily as the sun itself; by consequence the ever thoughtful Poppy had thought to require everyone in attendance to have dark shields over their eyes, remotely similar to a muggle's sunglasses. She had only a few years earlier begun her service at Hogwarts, but she was already an excellent Healer and perhaps the best head of the Hospital Wing the school had ever seen.

    "Do you really think it wise, Headmaster, for the students to take a trip together away from the school, with all that is going on?" she had asked in his office during the planning phase. Horace was already having the higher years brewing a lasting poultice to protect the students' skin.

    "There is no better time to go to the beach, Poppy," Albus responded. "When the days are well and truly dark, our duty is to remind the students that the sun will rise on the morrow. I should think it will be good for inter-House unity as well."

    With that it was decided.

    Setting up his beach chair and parasol with a wave of his wand, he watched as the students had the expected mixed reaction to being portkeyed to a strange beach in their swimsuits, with James Potter and his friends being the first in the water. Others were milling about in the sands, talking and exchanging pleasantries, though they seemed inclined to divide up into groups, which he hoped were not entirely based on House. Poppy, now lying on a towel next to him, had asked a few of the Prefects to get the students to play a game of volleyball with randomized teams. Her brow was decidedly knitted.

    "Worry not. I am sure once they have all been through the water, the Gryffindors will be more interested in a good sporting event."

    "I was looking at you, Headmaster."

    "Were you?" He was wearing an old fashioned striped swimming suit, with a fair few more colors than the standard black and white, which rather looked like prisoner garb in his opinion. In addition, he applied some of Horace's potion to his crooked nose.

    "Indeed. Your costume appears a touch... No, now that I have come this far I find I cannot say it."

    Albus merely winked before turning back to the students, getting out his binoculars. He had promised to watch them, but since few outside forces knew the trip was even happening, he doubted that there would be any trouble. It was only the graduating class that had come along, after all, so it was not as if the few faculty present could not supervise. There was also nothing explicitly stated in his guarantee of their safety that he would not watch some more than others.

    James Potter and his friends had apparently goaded most of the other boys into splashing each other, most likely assisting their efforts with magic. With no place to store their wands, the students had almost entirely left them with their uniforms, but the more talented among them were capable of a few tricks without them. It seemed that the students who had brought provisions had already realized there were no burners like in Potions class, but this would not deter them.

    A local man sauntered over with a tray of what appeared to be frilly, fruity drinks, which he levitated directly in front of Poppy. Reaching over her, he picked up one and asked to open a tab, leaving a galleon on the tray. Treating himself to the nearly nostalgic sensation of alcohol, he mentally commented that it truly had been a long time since he had been on vacation.

    Using once more his magical binoculars, it seemed Severus Snape was standing around alone, which was a common sight. It was evident that he had some sort of admiration for Lily Evans, but she was popular among the other witches, and consequently he could not bring himself to be near her. Albus mentally shrugged. His teenage awkwardness was one of the least concerning things he had learned about the boy; most other things he had learned from questioning Avery or Mulciber every time they were caught on rule violations.

    "You never seem to get caught yourself, do you, Severus?" he asked no one in particular. It appeared Poppy had her nose in a book. He turned to the other students who seemed to stand out for some reason, either because of their hair color or because their facial features were easily distinguished. "Perhaps the years are finally getting to my sight..."

    In any case, it seemed Peter Pettigrew was still lagging behind his friends and waited for others to come up with ideas, but he seemed content with the life of a follower. Remus Lupin was practically snarling with Sirius Black, who appeared to have found another use for the dark shields over his eyes; namely staring at a crowd of witches. His other friends copied him with perfect shamelessness, though Peter lacked such boldness. Looking over at Lily Evans and her group of friends, it appeared they had noticed quickly, some of them getting out their wands.

    "Lily! James is staring at your butt again!"

    "He had better- be sure to notify me if he stares at anyone else's and I'll hex him silly."

    "But I won't know if he's staring at someone else's butt!"

    "Then how did you know he was staring at mine in the first place?!"

    Looking back at the little gang, it seemed Sirius and James responded only with a high-five.

    "Just look at their faces, they're smirking!" Lily's Ravenclaw friend objected, her complaints falling on deaf ears. The scene was interrupted by more students jumping into the water, causing another magically enhanced splash, upsetting the sunbathers, if only temporarily. It seemed like they were inclined to run themselves out of energy before eating. He had every expectation they would eat with their friends, but the volley ball game promised to mix things up a little. Most of the pure blood children had not been introduced to the game, but apparently it was quite irresistible at beaches.

    "A pity Minerva had to send her regrets," he mused, heard only by Poppy. "She would have had the greatest of joy in disciplining the students for rule violations out here."

    "Perhaps, but she insisted on watching the castle and the younger students whilst you were away." The Healer turned her eyes back to the students as he did the same. "I also do not believe I have seen her in anything but professional robes, and she most certainly intends to keep it that way."

    The Prefects were assembling their Houses and calling for order as they counted off, directing either number to one side of the magical net or the other. It was quicker, he supposed, than getting them all into a line and making it so that only one student at a time could receive a number; as long as each Prefect named half one and half the other, the teams would be the same. Albus mused that it was almost pointless, with only seventh-years, to have prefects at all, but there were times and places he was glad for them.

    The game started quickly, with the teams decided at random and the ball either conjured or transfigured, with some students acting competitive, and others inclined only to have a good time with it, since it could not possibly count for points anyway. As he expected, those who grew up around muggles seemed to understand the game and its rules better than others. Sirius was throwing the ball over the net to allow the other team to serve.

    "Eva, maybe you should jump higher when you serve it!" he suggested. Remus was only shaking his head, but his nonverbal advice was ignored. The Headmaster looked away from her as she served again, though it seemed none of the younger wizards were similarly inclined. He sighed.

    "Really, Miss Parkinson, even I knew why he suggested it," Albus muttered. Rising, he ambled over on the pretense of officiating the game. It seemed the scores had been counted fairly thus far, but one could never be too careful. The last thing he wanted was accusations passed back and forth over the net instead of a ball. Without his influence, it seemed the students had added an additional rule to the effect that if a player missed a ball, he or she would be eliminated and replaced by one of the waiting students in the lines on either side of the net.

    However competitive it became, it looked like they were all having great fun.

    Lily Evans came up to him with a group of friends, possibly all having been eliminated. Behind them, Severus Snape appeared to be spying on her with his own associates.

    "Professor Dumbledore, it may be a little late to ask, but where exactly are we?"

    "It is never too late to ask questions, Miss Evans. We are on the rather large, rectangular island of Antillia in the Atlantic. There is a small wizarding population here, so now would be a good time to brush up on your Spanish if you and your friends have any intention of going into town."

    "I thought this place didn't really exist, though."

    "That's what we wanted you to think you stupid mudblood," Avery explained from behind her.

    "For what it is worth, you are both more or less correct. The muggle sailors who found this island could never find it again, so to muggles, it never existed. What happened was the Spanish wizards decided to capture it as an exclusively magical colony, and put up early muggle-repelling charms to keep the nonmagical away."

    "Interesting, Professor," Lily commented, still staring daggers at the Slytherins. Severus was looking elsewhere. It seemed a seagull had caught his attention.

    The volleyball game was down to a few students on each side, which made everyone want to watch. Several people were shouting at Peter, since it appeared to some that he had gone under the net, despite his insistence of having done no such thing. Albus apologized for having taken his eyes off the game for a moment and let it go. With the final point scored, Sirius picked up the Slytherin girl who had served it, putting her on his shoulder with a few of his teammates, to the momentary chagrin of his friend James, who was on the losing team.

    Dejection was easily forgotten as the students who had been working on the provisions apparently transfigured a grille with magical fire beneath, and everyone ate with excitement and appreciation. They seemed to take the opportunity to sit and talk with each other, and he was happy to see some of them appeared to be sitting with students from other Houses. Perhaps it was too late in their academic career to be making new friends, but the world would not be full of all their old friends when they moved out into it.

    "Butterbeer!" someone shouted. Albus's head turned. Of all the developments of the trip, this was the least expected. He knew not how the alcohol had been procured, but it was quickly handed out and students were drinking all around, some of them imbibing sterner stuff indeed. Poppy merely shook her head when he looked back.

    "Yes, perhaps it is no trouble; they are adults after all. Maudlin spirits are to be welcome at times like these." He took a sip or two of what tasted like firewhiskey that a giddy student handed him, perhaps to impair his judgement. "Clever, clever." He wondered how his brother had ever gotten into the business of selling such products; it had been many years since he had consumed any himself.

    Looking up, he noticed students were dancing in the sands. He laughed, thinking he should have seen it coming. They were getting a little blurrier with each sip of alcohol, so he walked over to see them better when he found himself getting pulled along into some muggle number called a hustle. Things seemed like they were going so well, he could hardly resist going along with the crowd. Time seemed to slow down as some of the heavier drinkers were already dropping. Looking back to the Healer, it seemed she had already disapparated.

    "Come students, the night is... yet young," he insisted, finishing the bottle. He heard several slurring cheers as his vision darkened, and he was sure his movements were getting slow and awkward. The last thing he could remember was landing on top of someone else who was already passed out.

    One Hundred Years Later

    The Master of Death sat across from him in a bitter cold room lit only by candles of blue flame. It had been many years since anyone had called him Harry, but that was still the name by which Albus knew him, wizened and grey though he was. His exposed skin was covered in scars both magical and mundane, but today there was a near smile, a recognition of the promise that the ritual was showing after all these years.

    It was a commonplace, obvious guess that the Hallows could complete each other, yet the careful enchantments the younger, living man had placed on the Resurrection Stone had thus far produced little results of interest, even with the Elder Wand. Suspending the Cloak of Invisibility over the stone, however, managed to 'hide' it, perhaps even from Death himself. The idea was, the old warlock supposed, child-like in its simplicity and symbolism, but it was evidently worth the effort. After an ancient ritual known only as 'Meeting at the River', Albus had, like Death from the tale, managed to take a corporeal form, if one bound to a specific place.

    The achievement had to be studied, of course, business before pleasure, though it was a bit of fun to discuss the magical theory with a former student as equals, especially in an entirely undiscovered field of study. At length they decided to shelve the discussion as Harry drank some sort of azure potion. He extended a conjured flask, but the older wizard waved it away.

    "I must decline, Harry, this discovery is a celebration in and of itself. I am quite honored to be chosen for these experiments, and I extend my gratitude that you respect my intention to embark on my next great adventure."

    "Come off it, Albus, you never have a drink to clear your head?" He looked down and to the left of his former student.

    "No, I find that more than anything it fills my head." The look in the green eyes across from him recalled the old adventure in the cave with the fake locket. "Terrible memories, painful memories...Many are an old man's mistakes... They say that in wine there is truth, and I believe I have told you-"

    "The truth is a beautiful and terrible thing. It should be treated with great caution." Harry put the bottle away. "You're right, Professor, I shouldn't be insisting."

    "Perish the thought- and please, I find I like being called Albus. I understand why you would assume I would want to celebrate the liberties of my regained physical form, but, if I am half as lucky as Professor Binns, there is the possibility a teaching career to consider."

    "Hogwarts would be glad to have you back."

    "Let us hope."
     
  2. BTT

    BTT Viol̀e͜n̛t͝ D̶e͡li͡g҉h̛t҉s̀ ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Aug 31, 2011
    Messages:
    461
    Location:
    Cyber City Oedo
    High Score:
    1204
    "Why doesn't Albus drink?" Well, why doesn't he? I've got no clue even after reading your story. The entire "beach episode" concept is cute but also it doesn't actually add anything. If Harry resurrected Dumbledore for teaching purposes (which is an idea that certainly merits consideration) then why is there this whole thing about heading to the beach? You're doing two entirely disparate things, idly tying them together for no real reason, and then submitting that as your entry. I don't get it.

    Also, someone calls Lily a "stupid mudblood" and Dumbledore does nothing? It's like calling someone the N-word in front of Martin Luther King. The fuck are you thinking, Avery? You can't even pretend anymore, when this should rightfully get your shit smacked?

    Dumbledore's resurrection would've been decent on its own, expanded into a full piece. As is, eh. 2/5.
     
  3. Shinysavage

    Shinysavage Madman With A Box ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2009
    Messages:
    2,084
    Location:
    UK
    High Score:
    2,296
    There's a couple of big issues with this for me, which unfortunately I'm probably going to spend more time on than the positives, simply because there's more to say on that front.
    Firstly, Avery calling Lily a mudblood - fine (you know what I mean). Avery calling Lily a mudblood in front of Dumbledore - really stupid. Or so you'd think, until Dumbledore doesn't even comment on it. Totally out of character.
    Secondly, this doesn't really feel like it has an ending. Albus blacks out after getting drunk with his students (which in and of itself is a little off, but OK), and then...it's 100 years later and a basically new story is starting. Obviously, it calls back to the main body of the entry, but it's a bit weird. Do I detect a bit of deadline panic? We've all been there!
    Thirdly, as far as the prompt goes, Dumbledore being a maudlin drunk is either a nicely understated twist or just a bit boring. Haven't quite decided yet.
    But, all that said, I did quite enjoy this. The mudblood moment aside, the beach trip was quite nicely done, a little sweet, a little sad. It's all technically fine. The timeskip is, as I say, disjointed from the rest of it, but it's interesting in and of itself. Not bad. 3/5
     
  4. Niez

    Niez Seventh Year ⭐⭐

    Joined:
    Jun 26, 2018
    Messages:
    294
    Location:
    Behind you
    The fuck is this weaboo shit, seriously. The Hogwarts Beach Trip Episode? I mean, I suppose it beats ‘Harry learns why Albus doesn't drink’, because, as pointed out by a previous review, he very much doesn’t. I suppose that if you take the snippet to operate on Anime logic the whole premise might work, but, as revealed by your ending, this seems to be a semi-serious story, which means that it does not.

    Why? Well, for one, the whole concept of a headmaster or teacher taking a bunch of teenage students to a beach is actually ludicrous, if not a lawsuit waiting to happen. You also implying that he is doing so (and changing their clothes) without their knowledge, which is just wild.


    Looking at the context, it’s even worse, given that there is a war currently happening (hand waves aside) and people are being killed left and right. But also, nothing actually happens. The students goof around, Albus desperately tries to hide his spiffy at the sight of James' apollonian body (presumably), and then he gets drunk. And then you tack on five hundred or so words that have nothing to do with the beach episode at the end, which actually rather changes the tone of the whole thing. I suppose you were on a fast approaching deadline and cobbled things together as best as you could (or modified a pre-existing idea to fit the prompt). To be clear, it's not bad at all for what it is, but what it is ‘s not much at all. Just don’t go for a beach episode next time, would be my advice.


    remotely similar? odd phrasing I have to say.

    under which metric lol. It’s just odd to pay her this much attention when she’s not even the subject of the story.

    ‘Oh yes, how do you do? Lovely weather we seem to be having… how's your muggle father? Dead? Oh my, how unfortunate.'

    what?

    Odd, its usually the opposite.

    behave, will you

    be sure to notify me? Is Lily talking to her friends or writing a letter?

    I very much doubt she would agree to this excursion to begin with.

    ambled? strange verb to use here

    I will refer you to the comments made by the previous reviewers on this topic.
     
  5. Blorcyn

    Blorcyn Chief Warlock DLP Supporter

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2010
    Messages:
    1,466
    Location:
    UK
    Love it. Subtle AUs, like this, where Dumbledore wouldn’t call out Avery calling Lily a Mudblood are always great.

    - I love the idea of Antilles the magical island being real and claimed by wizards. I always enjoy that sort of world building.
    - it’s an interesting choice to make it the time of the Marauders.
    - you had some comedic lines in here, and it was a relatively concise work of two scenes.

    + however, I’m not sure that I’d call there much approaching a plot, or a story here.
    + the central point of this, as far as I can tell, is that Dumbledore drank after a long time not drinking, got drunk, and then later reaffirmed that he’s not one for drinking.
    ++ a story should seek to externalise and force an internal change in a character. The perspective here is Dumbledore’s so we should perhaps be learning why he went off field trips, or that he was a permanent drunk and went off alcohol. You need to have a status quo, a flaw/way of viewing the world, then something that challenges these things. Events that push the main character to a point where they can change either to become much worse or much better by whatever measure, and make a good or bad choice that they couldn’t/wouldn’t have ever made at the start, finishing with a new status quo.
    + the final scene with Harry just seems purposeless to me. I guess you didn’t want to disturb canon, I can’t tell why. Your tone was light, but then you didn’t use it to make airy changes or conclusions. This could’ve been a lot more powerful.
    + the characterisation of all the characters just felt off. They didn’t feel like British teens in the seventies to me. Also, you introduced that we were in Antilles late, I thought the Scottish Coastline was being unreasonably hyped.
    + oh also, your distance was screwy, you lost orientation with your characters from Pomfrey to the rest, when he looked at them through binoculars (weird) then could also hear them without mentioning a charm, that I noticed.
     
  6. FitzDizzyspells

    FitzDizzyspells Seventh Year DLP Supporter ⭐⭐⭐

    Joined:
    Dec 4, 2018
    Messages:
    231
    I'm afraid I didn't like this one.

    So, Dumbledore's worst encounter with alcohol in his life is during a beach trip when he's about 90 years old? I guess it's supposed to be funny, but I'm sorry — it didn't really make me laugh.

    I mean, is that... really the most entertaining idea that the author could think of to explain why Dumbledore doesn't drink? He passed out during a field trip he was supposed to be chaperoning? Technically, he doesn't even experience any consequences. Not any we see, at least.

    Along the same lines, is this the best idea the author could think of to show how Harry finds out? That was a crazy tone change, from the first scene to the second scene. It really didn't work for me.

    I'm sorry that I don't have much constructive criticism, but this story doesn't really have much of a plot or character arc to analyze.
     
  7. Shouldabeenadog

    Shouldabeenadog Headmaster

    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2010
    Messages:
    1,004
    Location:
    California
    I don't get it.
    I don't get why albus doesn't drink. Is it because he passes out when he gets drunk? That's a fine point of mortality, but its not well emphasized if that is the point.
    The tone is supposed to be light humor I think, but the ending is dry and sober with severe tonal whiplash.
    You described a fairly banal beach scene, but while the characters were named correctly, there was so little of their characters that I couldn't say i learned anything new or saw a different side of any of them. Really the most interesting character was Avery, who said an insult that got Malfoy punched in front of Dumbledore and no one even batted an eyelash.

    There are a lot of good ideas in here. Theming that dumbledore gets drunk like the rest of humanity and really focusing on that would be great. A racous beach episode where things get WAY out of a hand because dumbledore got drunk could be interesting. Exploring mroe about Poppy and her relationship to dumbledore would be great. Those were some of your best parts.
     
Not open for further replies.